Archive for the ‘Petition’ Category

MSF Fights the Nutritional Double Standard at Food Aid Policy Conference

Friday, August 26th, 2011
Reactions from the MSF aid workers and staff who participated in the Kansas City meetings:

Last month, policymakers and representatives from various organizations involved in the international food aid system gathered in Kansas City, Missouri to assess current U.S. food aid policy

Several MSF aid workers and staff, including a pediatrician and a nutritionist who both recently treated malnourished children in MSF field clinics, attended the conference to give voice to the Starved for Attention campaign and promote the improvement of food aid quality.  As Dr. Susan Shepherd recently wrote in an opinion piece in the Kansas City Star,  “Investments in child health and nutrition programs should be based on what children need, no matter where they live.”

While some incremental progress was achieved with the release of a report by Tufts University experts calling for higher levels of key nutrients in corn-soy blend, a food aid staple, the MSF team reports that quicker and more significant changes are still needed to treat the millions of malnourished children around the world.

Press Release: Child Mortality Observed 50% Lower With Better Food

Tuesday, May 24th, 2011

PARIS/NIAMEY, May 24, 2011 – Mortality rates were observed to be 50 percent lower among a large group of young children in the west African nation of Niger in 2010, after they received a highly nutritious supplemental food, according to preliminary findings in a study by the international medical humanitarian organization Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF).

The encouraging findings reinforce the need for international donors and policymakers to make high-quality foods a cornerstone of childhood health programs, especially in areas where malnutrition is rife.

Malnutrition weakens the immune system, exposing a child to higher risk of death from other illnesses, such as malaria, respiratory infections, and diarrhea. Adding a quality supplemental food to an essential package of care—including vaccination and effective treatment and prevention of primary ‘killer diseases’ of young children—will accelerate the fight against child mortality.

Last year in Muskoka, Canada, G8 member states committed to refocus efforts over the next five years to cut mortality rates of children under five years of age, by two-thirds from 1990 levels. At their meeting this week in Deauville, France, G8 members should commit to ensure that appropriate foods reach vulnerable children, MSF said.

“Our preventive strategies focused on getting a nutritionally appropriate food to children during the most crucial time—the critical window of six months to two years of age—instead of waiting for them to start losing weight, and we observed child mortality rates to be lower by half,” said Dr. Isabelle Defourny, MSF program manager for Niger. “If donors and policymakers are serious about reducing child mortality rates, then providing child-appropriate foods must be made a standard component of any pediatric program in the world’s ‘malnutrition hotspots’.”

At any given time, an estimated 195 million children are affected by malnutrition worldwide. It contributes to at least one-third of the eight million annual deaths of children less than five years of age.

For several years, MSF has been developing preventive approaches to malnutrition—based on quality supplementary foods—in order to lower the burden of deaths in ‘malnutrition hotspots’ such as in the Sahel region of Africa. The Sahel features child mortality rates among the highest in the world. During a severe food and nutrition crisis in 2010 in the Sahelian country of Niger, local authorities, together with MSF and the Nigerien organization FORSANI (Forum Santé Niger), implemented the largest-ever distribution of supplemental foods designed to prevent malnutrition in young children.

Between July and December, 2010, three-to-six-month supplies of a ready-to-use paste rich in milk, minerals, and vitamins were distributed to approximately 150,000 children—most between 6 months and 2 years-of-age—in five districts of the Tahoua, Maradi, and Zinder regions. Some of the children also benefitted from protection rations (mainly cereals and fortified flours) provided by WFP. Pediatric healthcare for common childhood illnesses, such as malaria, and acute malnutrition, was also available in the distribution areas, including for the children who did not receive a nutritional supplement.

Epicentre, MSF’s epidemiology branch, conducted monthly surveys among a cohort of several thousand young children living in the distribution zones. All benefitted from monitoring for signs of malnutrition and illness. Children requiring medical care were referred to MSF and its partners working within Nigerien health-care facilities.

The mortality rate was seen to be more than 50 percent lower among those who received the foods tailored specifically to the nutritional requirements of young, growing children.

In the Madarounfa district in Maradi region, the observed mortality rate among children who received the enriched foods was 2.2 deaths per 10,000 children per day, compared to 5.3 deaths per 10,000 children per day among those who did not receive supplements. In the Guidan Roumji district of Maradi, mortality rates were 1.1 per 10,000 per day compared to 2.5 per 10,000 per day. In the town of Mirriah in Zinder region, the rates were 1.2 per 10,000 per day versus 3.2 per 10,000 per day.

“Providing young children with high quality nutritious foods has long been one of the foundational principles of successful malnutrition and child mortality reduction programs in Europe, Latin America and the United States, along with immunization, for instance,” said Dr. Susan Shepherd, MSF child nutrition advisor. “It’s time to stop applying different standards for children living in malnutrition hotspots. We can save children’s lives today if the appropriate resources are put behind similar interventions to those we deployed last year in Niger.”

Countries such as Mexico, Thailand, the United States, and many European nations, have successfully reduced early childhood malnutrition and mortality through programs that ensure infants and young children from even the poorest families have access to nutritious foods, such as milk and eggs. However, many food-insecure families cannot afford these animal-sourced foods, which contain the high-quality proteins, fats, and other essential nutrients that children require. National programs that fill this nutritional gap for young children are essential.

The development in recent years of a new generation of nutritional foods tailored to the needs of the most vulnerable children, which are simple to use, make possible the establishment of a new standard in childhood mortality prevention.

In 2010, in addition to malnutrition prevention activities, MSF and its partners, FORSANI and BEFEN / ALIMA, carried out pediatric and nutritional activities in 64 primary care facilities and nine hospitals in Niger’s Tahoua, Maradi and Zinder regions. Approximately 150,000 children suffering from malnutrition were treated—nearly half of all the malnourished children treated in the country in 2010—of whom approximately 24,000 were hospitalized. Between 85 and 92 percent of children were discharged. MSF and its partners also treated 216,330 cases of malaria among children less than five years of age, conducted more than 370,000 pediatric consultations, and admitted more than 13,000 children to hospital.

Starved for Attention Tours Spain

Friday, February 11th, 2011

MSF has organized a traveling multimedia exhibit that will tour six cities in Spain this month. The tour started last week in Barcelona and will end in March in Santiago de Compostela, stopping in Valencia, Malaga, Madrid, and Bilbao on the way.

A large screen projecting images from the Starved for Attention campaign will be on display in one of each city’s main plazas or train stations. MSF volunteers will be on site to answer questions and collect signatures for our petition calling for better quality food aid. The petition, which is addressed to governments supplying international food aid, is nearing 100,000 signatures.

Watch a video of the traveling exhibit here:

The mobile exhibit at the Barcelona Sants train station.

MSF volunteers gather petition signatures.

Open Letter to the U.S. Government About the Quality of Food Aid

Thursday, October 14th, 2010


The US Standard and A Double Standard
The access to nutritious, enriching foods that the U.S. government provides to young American children is a stark contrast to the nutritionally devoid blend of fortified flour sent to malnourished children outside the country.

Help us rewrite the story of malnutrition.
Sign the petition to change food aid policy.

The Starved for Attention campaign targeted other major food aid donors on World Food Day, urging them to do their part to improve the quality of food sent to malnourished children all over the world. Letters were sent to high-level administrators in the governments of the following countries:

To:
Secretary Hillary Clinton
U.S. Department of State
Administrator Rajiv Shah
U.S. Agency for International Development
Secretary Tom Vilsack
U.S. Department of Agriculture

On the eve of World Food Day 2010, I write on behalf of Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Borders (MSF) to urge the U.S. to stop supplying nutritionally substandard food to malnourished children in developing countries.

The U.S. is by far the world’s largest food assistance donor, accounting for more than half of global food aid in 2009. Its policies and practices are enormously influential in assuring that the right foods reach the right people at the right time. The main beneficiaries of food assistance are primarily young children and women. Yet the fortified foods in U.S. food assistance, including corn soya blend (CSB) and other fortified blended flours (FBF), are of an inappropriate nutritional composition for the primary target beneficiaries—particularly young children. MSF is reiterating a call to ensure that U.S. food aid meets the nutritional needs of young children.

MSF medical teams are frontline witnesses to the human devastation caused by malnutrition. An estimated 195 million children under five are malnourished; malnutrition contributes to one third of the 8 million deaths of children under five each year. In 2010, MSF is operating 120 nutrition programs in 36 countries. Already, our teams in Niger have treated more than 100,000 children for severe acute malnutrition this year. It is no accident that most of these acutely malnourished children are under 2 and fall within the critical window when quality diets make such a difference to health and development. As the U.S. government acknowledged during the launch of the “1000 Days” Campaign during the Millennium Development Goals Summit in September, the first two years of a child’s life provide a critical window of vulnerability and opportunity.

The U.S. government’s stated attention to malnutrition and maternal and child health directly conflicts with U.S. food aid policy. We understand that there is no one-size-fits-all solution to treating and preventing global childhood malnutrition, but making sure that food provided to children under the age of two meets nutritional needs is a minimum prerequisite.

After the first six months of breastfeeding, the types of complementary foods introduced into the diet are of paramount importance. The composition of U.S. sourced complementary foods provided through international food assistance—CSB—is contrary to overwhelming scientific evidence. It does not provide sufficient nutrients; it is high in anti-nutrients, inhibiting proper digestibility and absorption; and it contains no dairy products, important for growth.1 Diets that do not provide the right blend of high-quality protein, essential fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals can impair growth and development, increase the risk of death from common illnesses, or result in life-long health and developmental damage.

Nutritional experts under the auspices of the World Health Organization (WHO) reaffirmed in October 2008 the current formulations of FBF are not what young children need.2 The World Food Program (WFP) September 2009 nutritional implementation strategy now calls for food assistance received by the beneficiary population to meet their nutritional needs, and places a particular emphasis on children under the age of two. This should be indisputable. In a March 2010 letter to the EU, the nutrition directors of WHO, UNICEF and WFP reiterated the need for a change from FBF to meet the needs of young children.3 However, U.S. and EU policy have not changed.

Countries that have successfully reduced malnutrition—including Mexico, Thailand, the U.S., and many European countries—have done so through programs that ensure young children from the poorest families have access to quality foods. The U.S. government recognizes this. The domestic nutrition program, the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC), provides vouchers to low-income mothers for the purchase of high-value foods like milk, fruit, and eggs. Thus, the U.S. sends inadequate food overseas to vulnerable children that it would not use in its domestic nutrition programs.

U.S. international food assistance has not always been substandard. In the 1960s, when FBF was designed under the leadership of USAID, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), and the National Institutes of Heath (NIH), it contained milk powder, and was developed with a specification responding to then available nutritional science. But, when milk surpluses began to dry up in the 1980s and the price of milk escalated, the milk was removed, considerably weakening the nutrition composition of these foods. This practice has not changed.4

The U.S. has taken some steps recently towards moving food assistance to an appropriate nutritional standard, for instance with the USAID emergency responses in Pakistan and Haiti. The 2008 U.S. Farm Bill invites a reformulation of food aid to “meet nutrient needs of target populations.”  The food aid quality review being conducted by the School of Nutrition at Tufts University and an ongoing study of the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) examining nutrition in U.S. food aid are expected to add further evidence of the need for reform. But why should children have to wait for a catastrophic disaster or the results of further confirmatory studies to receive food assistance tailored to their needs?

We urge you to implement reforms so that addressing the needs of malnourished children is what drives the U.S. government’s international food assistance policy.

We request a meeting on this issue and would be available at your convenience.  Thank you for your time in this important matter.

Sincerely,

Sophie Delaunay, Executive Director

U.S Section of Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Borders (MSF)

  1. Shoham, Jeremy, et. al., “Proceedings of the World Health Organization: Consultation on the Management of Moderate Malnutrition in Children under 5 Years of Age.” Food and Nutrition Bulletin, 2009; 30(3): 464-474.
  2. Proceedings published in Food and Nutrition Bulletin 2009; 30 supplement 3.
  3. Joint position WFP/UNICEF/WHO with regard to the management of moderate malnutrition, using improved formulations of fortified blended flours sent to ECHO in March 2010.
  4. Marchione. TJ, History of Food and Nutrition in Emergency Relief Foods Provided through U.S. Government Emergency Food Aid Programs: Policies and Customs Governing Their Formulation, Selection and Distribution. The Journal of Nutrition, (2002) 132: 2104S–2111S.

Starved for Attention Advocacy – World Food Day

Saturday, October 9th, 2010

Emi Maclean, US Manager of MSF’s Access to Essential Medicines Campaign, talks about her upcoming meetings around World Food Day to advocate for greater resources in the fight against malnutrition.

Podcast: How the International Food Aid System Fails Children

Tuesday, September 7th, 2010

© Antonin Kratochvil/VII

The latest MSF Frontline Reports podcast examines the development of the staple product of international food aid – corn-soy blend (CSB) - and its lack of nutritional value.  MSF Nutrition Coordinator Dr. Susan Shepherd and Communications Director Jason Cone discuss corn-soy blend, the development of nutrient-rich alternatives, and the most effective ways to treat malnutrition.

Listen and learn more here.