Archive for July, 2010

How MSF Is Trying to Get the Right Foods to Children to Prevent Malnutrition

Friday, July 30th, 2010

Dr. Susan Shepherd

By Dr. Susan Shepherd, MSF Medical Advisor, just returned from Niger

In Niger, MSF Works Out Agreement to Add Nutrient-Rich Supplement to Food Aid for Malnourished Children

In terms of nutrition emergencies, 2009 was a relatively calm year for MSF—but still we treated about 250,000 children for acute malnutrition—100,000 children in Niger alone. 2010 is another story entirely. There are reports of increasing numbers of malnourished children from the eastern regions of Southern Sudan to Chad, and across the Sahel to Mali. Once again, the children of Niger appear to be facing a particularly difficult year. The UN agencies operating there estimate that as many as 340,000 children will develop severe malnutrition, and they are anticipating an unimaginable 1.2 million children will suffer from moderate malnutrition.

Treating even 80% of 340,000 severely malnourished children seems out-of-reach. Last year the health system with support from NGOs treated about 125,000 severely malnourished children. But UNICEF assures that it has the necessary medications and therapeutic foods lined up to meet this overwhelming need. As of mid June, the health system has already treated 114,000. Experience tells us that the health system will have to treat more than double this number before the end of October; it will also have thousands of patients – many young children – with malaria in the months of August to November.  Faced with numbers like this, what to do? Nurses, doctors and health workers in Niger already have more than enough to do. Reaching out to young children at risk of severe malnutrition and preventing them from losing weight is essential not only to protecting their health, but also to protecting the integrity of the health system.

The World Food Program (WFP) has launched large scale food distributions that provide grains and pulses (beans) for families, but these foods are lacking in the quality proteins, vitamins and minerals that young, rapidly growing children need. The WFP had planned to distribute a cereal porridge that contains some milk powder, but the supplies were not sufficient. So the back up plan is distribution of 8.3 kg per month of corn-soy blend [CSB] to 500,000 children under two years old for May through July, and an astounding 925,000 under 2’s for August and September. Already there have been distribution delays because CSB must be mixed with oil and sugar; the oil stocks were blocked in transport which meant that the June distribution took place two weeks late. Much of this food comes from far away. About half of the tonnage of CSB will come from the USA.

A young Nigerien eats ready to use therapeutic food at the Intensive Nutritional Rehabilitation Centre (CRENI) supported by MSF in Guidan Roumdi. ©Alessandra Vilas Boas/MSF

CSB is not the right food for young children. The protein quality is poor compared to milk or eggs, the porridge often is diluted in order to make it stretch further (many families report that the ration that was meant to last 1 month is gone in 1 week), and the balance of vitamins and minerals is not tailored to children’s needs. MSF has worked out an agreement with the Government of Niger and WFP to add on a ready-to-use food supplement to the CSB distribution for about 120,000 children in the areas where we have nutrition programs. The WFP is planning to provide ready-to-use food supplements to all 925,000 children, at least for the month of September. One month is better than none, but we need to do better.

Of the organizations distributing food, many are local groups. MSF is partnering with Nigerien organizations for distribution of special foods for children under 2s and for treatment of malnourished children. A small daily amount of about 45 grams of the ready-to-use supplement, or three tablespoons, should substantially improve diet quality for these young children. It provides milk powder, mixed into peanut butter with added vitamins and minerals tailored to the needs of young, rapidly growing children. The idea is that they will be better protected against weight loss and illness.

Although it is pretty widely accepted that young children need special foods, “baby food,” to meet their nutritional requirements, until very recently this concept has not been integrated into international food assistance. A one year old child is given the same food rations, in quantity and quality, as a 50 year old: generally cereals, pulses and some oil. Fortunately, this is starting to change. To help accelerate and expand this change, it is important to carefully document the impact of these improved food distributions on the health and growth of young children. Epicentre, the epidemiologic research center founded by MSF, is working closely with the Ministry of Health to monitor and evaluate how children do and what families think of this new “baby food.”

The children in Niger, and millions of others in similar situations, are at the heart of the Starved for Attention campaign. Let’s work towards convincing others that quality diets for young children make a big difference.

Dr. Susan Shepherd is a pediatrician who has worked full-time for Doctors without Borders/Médecins sans Frontières for the past 4 years. She currently coordinates MSF’s work in nutrition. Dr Shepherd’s interest in childhood malnutrition has grown out of her time in the field; she began volunteering with MSF in 2003 in a pediatric ward in Uganda, then in 2005 worked in a nutrition program in Chad during a measles epidemic. In the aftermath of the 2005 nutritional crisis, she worked in Niger for almost 2 years as a field doctor and then as medical coordinator. She appeared on CBS’ 60 Minutes in October 2007 while in Niger, advocating for MSF’s new approach to treat and prevent malnutrition. In addition to working for MSF, Dr Shepherd has spent time at the Children’s Hospital in Accra, Ghana as a Yale/Johnson & Johnson Physician Scholar in International Health. Dr. Shepherd received her BA in biology from Lawrence University in Wisconsin, and her MD from Université Libre de Bruxelles in Belgium. She completed her residency in pediatrics at the University of Chicago. Prior to joining MSF full-time she worked as a general pediatrician in Butte, Montana.

How WIC Works

Wednesday, July 28th, 2010

By Deborah A. Frank, MD
Director, Grow Clinic for Children, Boston Medical Center
Founding Principal Investigator, Children’s HealthWatch
Professor of Pediatrics, Boston University School of Medicine

Stephanie Ettinger de Cuba, MPH
Research and Policy Director, Children’s HealthWatch

In 1967 in his role as senator from New York, Bobby Kennedy visited the American South to see firsthand children suffering from severe malnutrition due to poverty. This trip and the CBS documentary “Hunger in America” helped finally bring the issue of hunger to the attention of the nation. 

Boston Medical Center's Food Pantry

  

 In 1968, a group of physicians met with government officials and told them of the young women, often pregnant, who came to their clinics suffering a variety problems related to malnutrition. Their solution was to create food commissaries connected to neighborhood clinics, where women would obtain food packages by prescription. In 1974, the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC) as we know it began.  

WIC is a now national success story – a food prescription program with extensive scientific evidence of its effectiveness in supporting the health of pregnant women, nursing mothers and young children in the critical period of brain growth.  

One Minneapolis mother explained that WIC kept her healthy during pregnancy:  

“WIC helped me a lot because they used to give me a lot of fruits and vegetables. … I think I was healthy. That was one of the reasons why I was so healthy. … But I was able to eat all these fruits and vegetables and drink milk and the peanut butter and the protein… So that helped a lot. I think WIC is awesome.”  

To participate, households must meet income eligibility criteria and state residency requirements and be determined to be at “nutritional risk” by a health professional. WIC participants receive monthly vouchers to purchase foods high in the essential nutrients often dangerously lacking in the diets of low-income families. In addition, WIC links women and children with health care by integrating its services with others that are necessary for children’s well-being. WIC’s public health workers, for example, screen all immunization records of infants and children under age two and provide referrals to immunization services and nutrition education.  

WIC Improves Child Health and Development  

There is a long history of research showing that WIC is good medicine for mothers and young children – medicine which spares the public purse by decreasing low birth weight, Failure to Thrive, and anemia, and increasing immunization rates. Recently, new research from Children’s HealthWatch, a pediatric research center collecting data in five U.S. cities, has shown that WIC also decreases very young children’s risk of developmental delays.  

Children’s HealthWatch has shown that:  

  • WIC decreases the risk of developmental delays in young children. Young children are considered at risk for developmental delays when families note that their ability to speak and understand language, use small and large muscles, and regulate their social/emotional behavior is less than other children their age. By reducing the risk of early developmental delay, WIC helps children to be ready to learn when they enter school.
  • Children under age three who receive WIC are more likely to be in good health than children who are eligible but do not receive WIC due to difficulties accessing the program. They are also more likely to be food secure and have a healthy height and weight for their age, neither over nor underweight.
  • WIC has its most protective effect on children younger than 12 months old. It is during this period that young children’s brains more than double in size if the nutritional building blocks are provided.
  • Although WIC is good medicine, only 57 percent of those eligible are enrolled. Women interviewed by Children’s HealthWatch reported a range of barriers to accessing the program, including lack of a permanent address, limited office hours at some WIC offices, and difficulty getting to the WIC office to pick up vouchers because of work or other responsibilities. As state budgets are cut back, the hours and staffing of WIC services dwindle despite increasing need. The challenges are particularly grave for impoverished rural and suburban families living where there is no public transportation and often no car.

Preventive Nutritional Care In Practice  

At Boston Medical Center (BMC) some of these access issues have been resolved by locating the WIC Office right in the hospital. Families referred to WIC by their physicians need only go down the hallway to talk to WIC nutritionists. In addition, the WIC office shares space with a very unique and innovative operation, the Preventive Food Pantry, the first hospital-based food pantry in the country, established because clinicians were so frustrated that their patients were suffering from serious illnesses due to an inability to afford a healthful diet. BMC’s food pantry is “preventive” in that it provides therapeutic diets to all family members and addresses disorders often linked to malnutrition and hunger in all age groups, like diabetes or hypertension in the elderly or growth failure in babies.  

Around the world, diets inadequate in quantity and quality are among the most treatable and most preventable threats to the health and learning potential of children and families. WIC represents a successful, uniquely American model for getting healthful nutrition to our mothers and children.  

About Children’s HealthWatch
Children’s HealthWatch monitors the impact of economic conditions and public policies on the health and well-being of young children. Our network of pediatricians and public health researchers collects data in hospital emergency rooms and primary care clinics in five research cities: Baltimore, Boston, Minneapolis, Little Rock and Philadelphia.

Southern Sudan: MSF Expands Activities as Nutritional Situation Worsens

Monday, July 26th, 2010

In the last few months, a combination of bad harvests and growing insecurity has resulted in a huge increase in the rates of malnutrition in Southern Sudan. While Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) is responding to the crisis, more feeding centers, specialized food, and staff are needed to prevent needless deaths of Sudanese children.

Here, MSF Emergency Coordinator in Southern Sudan Moses Chol explains how MSF is expanding activities so that more nutritional aid will reach the regions that desperately need it.

What is the nutritional situation in Southern Sudan today?

The situation is extremely worrying, especially in the Upper Nile region. Over 800 children are being treated in MSF’s feeding centers in Unity State alone. The annual hunger gap is not entirely to blame for this, as there was a 200 percent increase in the number of children treated as compared to the same period last year.

Why do you think the situation is so bad this year?

There is a combination of factors, but the main one is the scarcity of food. Basically, we are six or eight weeks away from the harvest and there is very little food to be found in the market. The price of the main staple food, sorghum, has more than doubled since last year, resulting in people having to sell capital assets such as goats and cows to buy basic foodstuffs. There are significant gaps in basic healthcare, whereby patients have to walk for several hours to receive the most basic of treatments, which contributes to children getting sick and further weight loss. But of course, the violence and insecurity also make things even worse.

There are some pockets of violence where tribal disputes or more political post-election clashes have happened. Whatever the root of the violence, many families have had to flee their homes and therefore cannot farm their land. This has been a direct impact on the agricultural output and families’ capacities to feed themselves.

We have managed to find some local partners who we have trained and helped with supplies, but there is a real need for more people to expand their interventions in the country to tackle this acute crisis.

How did MSF react to the upsurge in malnutrition?

As we saw the numbers going up, we first made sure that we could deal with the increasing number of patients in our own clinics and feeding centers. In many places, we’re pretty much the only aid organization providing nutritional support. But we also figured that if the situation was bad where we were, it was probably at least as bad in other areas where there was no health actor providing assistance.

When analyzing the origins of our patients in our feeding center in Leer, we found that 15 percent of patients were coming from the capital of Unity State, Bentiu, over 100 kilometers (62 miles) from Leer—this is what led us there.

You were part of the team doing the assessment in Bentiu. What was the situation when you got there?

Bentiu is a big town of about 100,000 inhabitants where 80 percent of the people are unemployed and rely heavily on humanitarian aid. Ironically, during the war, they could count on regular food distributions, but this has stopped with the peace agreement.

Bentiu has a relatively big hospital, but the staff there did not have the capacity to respond to the nutritional emergency. Children are admitted for an array of pediatric conditions, but cannot be treated for malnutrition because the hospital staff have no specialized food for therapeutic feeding.

When we visited the hospital for the first time, they had admitted four children suffering from malnutrition, but two had died. The staff there told us that the only thing they could provide was counseling to the families of the two others. There was a lack of supplies, human resources and training, which meant that starting to treat malnutrition was not even an option.

That’s when MSF decided to intervene?

As we’re already intervening in many parts of Southern Sudan, we tried to encourage the authorities and other organizations to get involved in Bentiu. But there are very few organizations with spare capacity to go beyond their current program areas, and in Bentiu there was no one present in a position to react.

What will MSF do to improve the situation?

Our team has opened two feeding centers in Bentiu hospital. The first one provides intensive care for children who need to be hospitalized and carefully monitored. The second center provides ambulatory feeding care which means that mothers can come with their children to be weighed and measured, and then receive specialized therapeutic food that they can take home to administer, only having to return to the center after a week or two.

Within three days of the feeding centers opening in Bentiu, 28 children were hospitalized and 70 children were enrolled in the ambulatory feeding program.

Once we identify where most of the affected kids are coming from, we may open new ambulatory structures in different areas, but keep referring the kids who are worst off to Bentiu for hospitalization.

In addition to providing lifesaving care to malnourished children in and around Bentiu, the MSF team will focus on training local health staff to treat malnutrition so that the capacity to respond remains even after MSF’s departure.

Can MSF do more?

MSF is already intervening in many parts of Southern Sudan, often as the only organization treating malnutrition. We have managed to find some local partners whom we have trained and helped with supplies, but there is a real need for more people to expand their interventions in the country to tackle this acute crisis.

How long will MSF stay in Bentiu?

That’s not an easy question, but we hope that the nutritional situation will improve after the harvest and that the hospital staff will be able to manage the remaining cases. Our initial plan is to stay for three or four months. We will reassess the needs at that time and we may well have to stay longer if the needs are there.

Malnutrition: Hundreds of Thousands of Children Under Threat in Sahel

Monday, July 26th, 2010

Throughout Africa’s Sahel region, MSF works to treat and prevent malnutrition during a particularly extreme food and nutrition crisis.

Interview with Photojournalist John Stanmeyer

Thursday, July 22nd, 2010

VII photographer John Stanmeyer traveled to rural areas of Oaxaca State in Mexico to shoot “A Solution from Within”, which documents the area’s successful Progresa/Oportunidades nutrition safety net program, for the Starved for Attention project.

PBS Need to Know: Malnutrition, the Silent Epidemic

Saturday, July 17th, 2010

Need to Know takes a closer look at the global malnutrition epidemic, the unexpected role that U.S. food policy plays in perpetuating it and some new ideas for improving nutrition for those who need it most.


Watch the full episode. See more Need To Know.

Coverage of Starved for Attention: Featured Slideshows

Friday, July 16th, 2010

“We tend to think of [the image of malnutrition] as a lonely child in the middle of nowhere with a vulture hanging over her. It’s not like that at all. There is a very concerned family. Hundreds of doctors go into making these children well again.”  – Photographer Marcus Bleasdale, quoted in NYTimes.com’s Lens Blog

See more coverage of the Starved for Attention photographs in these recent slideshows and articles:

Producing the Documentaries: “A Solution From Within”

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

The Starved For Attention multimedia documentary videos were produced by Herzliya Films. The company was founded in 2002 by Jeremiah Zagar and Jeremy Yaches as an outlet to create highly original and emotional stories for a global audience, and specializes in producing films, documentaries, commercials and movie trailers for large and small screens.

Herzliya Films

Zagar, creative director for the project, and editor Galen Summer worked on John Stanmeyer’s material from Mexico to create “A Solution From Within”. Here they discuss the process of creating that piece and the experience of working on Starved For Attention:

Jeremiah Zagar to Galen Summer: The Mexico piece is so full of life, joy and humor which is not so present in the other short films. How did you, John Stanmeyer, and Jason Cone (MSF-USA’s director of communications) work together to bring that piece to life?

Galen: Really, the humor, life, and personality present in the Mexico film comes from the Oaxacan people. John Stanmeyer beautifully captured the character of the Oaxaca region of Mexico by gaining access to the people and putting himself in the right place at the right time. It helped that he had a bit of luck as well. For example, John told me that he was on his way to visit Librada Torres, the woman who we see giving birth at the clinic, in her home in the mountains when he happened to see a pickup truck speeding toward him on the road. This truck was carrying Librada and her husband to the clinic and John just happened to be traveling on that same road at that very moment. He was able to jump in the back of the truck and be there with them all through the extraordinary process of Librada giving birth.

Not only did John take some really insightful and affecting photographs, but he also managed to capture some very intimate, personal moments on video. So as an editor I had all these great little human interactions to work with, and it really became about trying to find those moments that most engaged me as a viewer, where the people were expressive and open, and just seemed to be natural. One of my favorite scenes is when a group of men in a remote village, raise a loudspeaker up a flag pole so that one of them can announce through a microphone the arrival of the doctors in the town. The young man on the microphone is a bit nervous and awkward, and there is something touching about that. It really shows the communal aspect of the whole thing, that everyone is called upon to pitch in, whether they are a professional or not.

So I guess the life, the energy, and the humor was all there, the trick was finding the pieces that best conveyed what the Mexican government and Mexican people were doing right. Jason Cone really wanted to emphasize how the Oportunidades Program, which is the government-run health program we profiled in this film, was successful because it was run by local people for locals. This meant that we needed to see things on a human scale – personal interactions, private moments between doctors and patients, young parents at home with their newborn baby. The goal was to show how this program is integrated into the daily lives of the people, so in that way it really had to be about everyday life.

Interview with Photojournalist Franco Pagetti

Wednesday, July 7th, 2010

For “The Malnutrition That Shouldn’t Be”, VII photojournalist Franco Pagetti traveled to North Kivu Province, Democratic Republic of Congo.

Coverage of Starved for Attention: Featured Articles

Wednesday, July 7th, 2010

“Give the children what they need, not what is left over. Treat the young children of developing countries the same way you would treat your own children.” – Dr. Susan Shepherd, MSF, quoted in an Inter Press Service article, June 5th 2010

Read more about the campaign and malnutrition in these featured pieces:

  • Marcus Bleasdale’s haunting photographs of malnutrition in Djibouti in Foreign Policy
  • Global Patriot post on Starved for Attention and malnutrition
  • Interview with photojournalist Ron Haviv in Journalism Now
  • IRIN feature on the Starved for Attention campaign